Pennsylvania Lifers Fight to Break Legislative Stalemate, and Find a Pathway Out of Prison

November 17, 2026

Bolts: “In March, the more than 1,000 people sentenced to life without parole for felony murder convictions in Pennsylvania finally had hope that they might not die in prison after all.

That’s when the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that the state’s especially harsh practice of automatically sentencing people to life without parole for felony murder—a charge allowing prosecutions for murder due to someone’s involvement in a crime that led to a death, even if they didn’t personally cause or participate in the killing—violated the state constitution’s protections against ‘cruel punishments.’ Pennsylvania was one of just two states to mandate that anyone convicted of felony murder, which is classified as second-degree murder in the state, receive a sentence of life without parole.

While the ruling only changed things for single person at that moment—Derek Lee, who was sentenced to life without parole more than a decade ago for his participation in a 2014 burglary in which his accomplice fatally shot the homeowner during a struggle—it looked like the court’s decision in his case could pave a pathway out of prison for more than 1,000 Pennsylvanians serving a mandatory life without parole sentence for felony murder. Even though the court declined to make its decision retroactive, it gave the legislature a 120 day deadline to ‘consider appropriate remedial measures.’…

‘While the Pennsylvania legislature has failed to address retroactivity, despite bipartisan support for this general idea, we look to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to ensure that its decision in Lee is fairly applied to more than a thousand people serving a life sentence for felony murder,’ Rupalee Rashatwar, managing attorney of the Abolitionist Law Center, which is representing Coffey, told Bolts. She called the court’s decision to consider Coffey’s case ‘the culmination of decades of organizing against death by incarceration sentences.'”

read the full article

Photo: AP Photo/Ted Shaffrey