FAQ About the Derek Lee Felony Murder Ruling

On March 26, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a mandatory life without parole (LWOP) sentence – death by incarceration (DBI)– for the crime of 2nd-degree murder, which is Pennsylvania’s felony murder statute, violates Article 1, Section 13 of the Pennsylvania Constitution, which prohibits “cruel punishments.” The questions below address the basics of the ruling, which is, without question, good news for everyone serving 2nd-degree sentences—even if the Supreme Court judges left unanswered the question about whether this ruling will be applied retroactively to the roughly 1,100 people serving this sentence. On September 29, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed to address the question of Lee‘s retroactivity in the case Commonwealth v. Coffey.

Timelines and next steps for people now serving 2nd-degree sentences aren’t yet clear, and won’t be until the Supreme Court addresses retroactivity. You can also watch a discussion of these questions and more at an October 20, 2026 webinar about the ruling.

Action Steps for Loved Ones and Any Supporter on the Outside

We’ll be keeping steady pressure on the legislature and decision-makers until this situation is resolved and everyone has a chance to come home. We’ll need a lot of help, though, more than we have now; please ask anyone you know to help support us and our allies at bit.ly/2nd-chance-2nd-degree